Start Smart: Why Early Decisions Define the Success of Your Search

I see it happen time and time again. A company has a critical role to fill and jumps straight into action. The job description gets posted. Emails go out. Recruiters are called. LinkedIn gets lit up. There’s energy, momentum, and urgency. But then, ten days pass. Then thirty. And before long, they’re still searching, still interviewing, and wondering what went wrong.

The truth is, what happens in the first 48 hours of a search doesn’t just set the tone. It determines the outcome. It defines the direction, the speed, and the success of everything that follows.

A Real Conversation That Says It All

A few months ago, I talked to a company that had been working on a search since the previous November. By the time they reached out in June, the role had been open for seven months. They had been through multiple interviews, made offers, and had two turn-downs. Now they were heading back to the market.

When they asked for my take, I told them what I usually tell teams in this spot: if this had started with the right foundation, it could have been done in days, not months. That’s not dramatic. That’s just the truth. I’ve seen it play out hundreds of times.

The problem wasn’t effort. It was alignment. They jumped into execution by posting the job, calling people, and setting up interviews before stopping to define what success actually looked like. Without that clarity, everything that comes next gets harder.

Strategy First, Not Second

Before you do anything else, before you email your recruiter, post a job, or start calling your network, you need to stop and ask the right questions.

What are we trying to solve with this hire? Where are we right now in our growth journey, and where do we need to go next?

Is this person going to manage internal systems? Will they oversee external partners? Are we looking for someone to maintain stability or to drive transformation?

These aren’t just job spec questions. They’re business questions. And the clearer you are on the answers, the stronger your search will be.

Success Starts with Clarity

Too often, companies think about roles as lists of responsibilities. But responsibilities don’t tell you where you’re going. They don’t define what success looks like.

In the first 48 hours, you need to map the mission. What will this hire need to achieve in the next 12 to 18 months? What outcomes are you holding them accountable for? And just as importantly, what kind of person do you want in the room?

Do you need someone who thrives in ambiguity or someone who craves structure? Are you building a culture of experimentation or one of operational excellence?

Get clear on the person before you chase the profile.

Get Real About Compensation

This is where a lot of searches fall apart, and it’s entirely preventable. If you don’t understand the current market compensation for the type of talent you want, you’re setting yourself up for failure.

I’ve seen it too many times. A hiring manager falls in love with a candidate, only to find out they’re twenty or thirty thousand dollars apart on salary. And that gap doesn’t close. Not in this market. Not when talent has options.

It’s even more complicated when you’re working your personal network. Maybe your friend wants 240, but your boss only wants to approve 215. Now you’re negotiating with someone you know, and things get awkward fast. If your friend is worth 240, they’re not taking 215. You’ve wasted time and risked a relationship. You need to know the numbers before the conversations start. Not during. Not after.

Location Isn’t a Footnote

This might seem like a minor detail. It’s not.

Do you want this person in New York? Are you open to Houston? Is the role remote? Hybrid? Are you hoping they’ll relocate eventually?

You need to decide that early. And once you do, hold the line. The fastest way to lose momentum in a search is to start changing the rules mid-process.

Consistency shows seriousness. Flip-flopping shows indecision. And top candidates can smell that from a mile away.

The Trap of the Perfect Candidate

Even experienced hiring teams fall into this one. You put together a beautiful job description filled with every ideal skill, tool, and experience you can imagine. You circulate it and wait for perfection to apply.

And sometimes, it looks like they have.

But lately, I’ve been hearing the same thing from multiple hiring managers. Candidates look great on paper. Then the interview starts, and something’s missing. The knowledge isn’t there. The depth isn’t real. They’ve clearly tailored their resume with the help of AI to match your checklist, but they can’t deliver.

The solution is not to make the list longer. It’s to make it sharper.

Less Is More

Focus on the two or three most critical things this person must do well. The dealbreakers. The essentials. Once you’ve defined that, shift your attention to who they are.

Are they adaptable? Are they curious? Do they understand your culture and care about staying for the long term?

That’s where your best hires live. Not in the perfect resume. In the person who has the must-haves and the mindset.

Don’t Overcrowd the Search

This might be one of the most misunderstood parts of hiring. When companies are feeling pressure, they often bring in multiple recruiting firms, thinking they’ll get more coverage, more speed, more options.

What they actually get is noise.

Candidates hear about the same role from multiple people. The messaging gets distorted. The employer brand starts to look scattered and uncoordinated. And top talent starts wondering, is this even a serious search?

When a candidate hears from three different sources about the same role, they don’t feel special. They feel like a commodity. That is not the experience you want to deliver.

Choose Your Partner and Stay Committed

Whether you choose to go retainer or contingency, make that decision with intention. Then stick with it.

A dedicated recruiter, working exclusively, isn’t juggling three versions of your story. They’re shaping your narrative with precision. They’re presenting you to the market with focus and consistency.

Exclusivity doesn’t limit your reach. It strengthens your voice. It delivers a better candidate experience. And most importantly, it moves faster, because everyone is aligned.

Reputation Has a Shelf Life

Every extra week that a search drags on, the harder it gets. Not because there are fewer candidates. But because the reputation of the role starts to shift.

People start asking why it’s still open. They wonder what’s wrong with the position. With the company. With the team. And suddenly, your best prospects are hesitant to engage.

The clock isn’t just ticking on your timeline. It’s ticking on your credibility.

Why the First 48 Hours Matter Most

If you take nothing else from this, remember this: the first 48 hours are your foundation. They are your opportunity to get aligned, set expectations, and define success.

Once interviews start, things move quickly. Decisions have to be made. Timelines compress. The last thing you want is to be figuring things out on the fly.

Planning in those early days doesn’t slow you down. It sets you up to move fast when it matters.

The Right Start Saves You Weeks Later

The time you spend at the front end saves you exponentially more time on the back end. It avoids resets, misfires, and missed opportunities. It keeps the message clean, the process tight, and the experience positive for everyone involved.

So take those first two days seriously. Be honest about what you need. Be decisive about how you’ll find it. And be intentional in who you trust to lead the charge.

Final Thoughts

Hiring isn’t just about filling a position. It’s about solving a problem. Building a team. Creating momentum.

When you start with purpose, you finish with results.

So the next time you’re gearing up for a search, take a breath. Ask the hard questions. Get the plan right before the posting goes live.

Because the first 48 hours will determine everything that follows.

About The Author:
Steve Swan has been in the executive search game for over two decades, with a sharp focus on biotech, life sciences, and enterprise technology. He’s built his career on one core principle: tell it like it is. Known for delivering hard truths with heart, Steve partners with clients who want clarity, speed, and real results—not fluff. Whether he’s helping companies land mission-critical hires or navigating the nuances of culture fit, Steve brings a level of insight that only comes from having seen thousands of deals play out, for better or worse. Outside the search world, he’s a former mountain bike racer, a committed cancer charity rider, and a firm believer that every candidate and client conversation matters.

Are you looking for top IT talent in the pharmaceutical or biotech industry?

Contact us to discuss how we can bring top-tier IT talent to your organization. The Swan Group are executive leaders with extensive IT recruiting expertise in the biotech and pharmaceutical space. Our goal is to ensure that each professional we place and each client we work with achieves a competitive advantage based upon our services.

Are you a professional looking for a new opportunity?

Contact us to discuss your career options or browse our opportunities. As a small boutique firm, we are in the business of building careers, not just filling positions.

ABOUT THE SWAN GROUP

Our goal is to ensure that each professional we place and each client we work with achieves a competitive advantage based upon our services. Our specialty is high-level INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY placement within the Pharmaceutical, Bio-Pharmaceutical, and Consumer Products industries. Thoughts, comments, or would like to discuss further, please contact us.